ryan9939 | 06-18-2011 12:44 AM | Guys, here is the situation regarding players being goalies. In fact, here is the memo refs and scorekeepers all received (well the significant part at least).
"To all scorekeepers, rosters are now frozen so no write-ins should be allowed. Teams will be notified that if they need an emergency goalie, they will have to clear it with the league ahead of time. Please continue to notify Bryan by email (bryan@vihl.net) about any teams playing without a goalie so that they can be fined or any skaters playing as a goalie or vice versa."
As soon as the scorekeeper noticed that the person in net wasn't a registered goalie for your team, I had to enforce the rule I was told to enforce, and not let him play. The scorekeeper brought it to our attention, not the other way around. I asked someone on your team wearing an A if they had cleared it with the league first, and they responded "no" (I don't know who it was, and I did ask for the captain, but was told he wasn't there...fine). As a result, it is my job to enforce the rules, as they're written, and not make them up by what I feel is "fair". It's about consistency! If it was up to me, he would have played with no issue since he was on the roster. I don't think it should matter whether a skater is playing as a goalie as long as he is on the roster. Again, I don't make the rules, and that's one rule I certainly don't agree with. After that game, I spoke with Bryan, as we work very closely discussing a large range of league matters, and a new memo was sent out regarding this issue:
"A player who is registered to a team "IS" allowed to play goalie for that team for the game... goalies however are not allowed to play player.... there has been some confusion on that.. hope this clears it up... thanks"
So the fact is referees/scorekeepers received conflicting information on this rule within a 3 day span. We received that last memo today after a couple other incidents at other rinks regarding the same issue the other night.
It sucks that it happened, and it's not what anyone wanted, even the refs, but it's just one of the rules that even I didn't agree with, and I'm glad that today it was clarified. Unfortunately, I know that doesn't change what happened yesterday though. It was a stupid rule, just like an accidental high stick causing blood being an automatic game misconduct... Horrible rule, but it exists and I've had to enforce it, several times, even though it makes my stomach churn. I feel the game misconduct aspect of it should be at the referee's discretion, and I hate having to call it. My goal is to make sure games go smoothly, that they're reffed consistently by the book, and that they're fair.
Let me make one thing clear, before you go discrediting my ability, let me give you some background information about myself:
a) I have been playing recreational inline hockey every year for the last 15 years
b) I have been involved in this league since year 1 as a player (2004), and shortly thereafter got my NIHA certification to be a ref (2005).
c) I have played in Silver and Gold for the last 5 years as a player (both defense and forward)
d) I'm a top level ref in this league, and am only 1 of a small few who are qualified to referee top level games at Karen Magnussen (which are the majority of the games that I do ref).
e) I have reffed more games this year than any other referee, and have done about 150 games so far this season.
And you know what? This is the first complaint that I've received over the last 2 years! To be honest, it doesn't bother me one bit because I enforced the rule that I was told to enforce! Some guys ref 20-30 games a season and will get multiple complaints! I'm pretty confident in my ability to call a game properly.
Thrilla, before you go running your mouth, I'd love to hear your qualifications and hockey experience. You can call me a retard all you want, but in case you're interested, I have a degree in Business Administration from SFU, have a well paying job, own my own condo in the lower Lonsdale area of North Vancouver (and no, I was not Powered by Mom), as well as run my own IT business on the side. I don't think that sounds too retarded, but lets hear your story?
Anyway, I'm sorry your team lost the way they did. It's not what I wanted, but it's what I was told to do by my employer, at the time. If you have any further issues you want to discuss, I'd be more than willing.
I don't check this thread too often but please PM me if you want me to respond to anything. |