Rate The Picture Above You
 

This thread is about rating a picture from a photographic stand point. Please post a picture, and give some positive and negative feedback on the photo above the one you posted.

Every post should have a picture, and the person following will rate it from 1 (:facepalm:) - 10 (:fuckyea:)

I know we have the Daily Showcase, and that's great. People post alot in that thread, but alot of people never say anything about the picture you've posted. Now you get feedback all the time! Please be respectful, and useful in your feedback.

Enjoy the thread! Cheers!

I'll start!

The Apostles
http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6153/6...25d2bfc0_b.jpg

Great Idea!

I rate your pic 8/10 cause i like the fact it doesnt seem too edited and has very soothing tones although composition could have been a tad better. Makes me feel like im back in mexico :)

http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6224/6...0f0d4199_b.jpg

like that one, but going to deduct for a visible power line. 8.5

http://www.epicdevelopements.com/wp-...eagleyoung.jpg

Could use a little post processing. 8/10

http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6219/6...1bf308cb_b.jpg

Not a bad start to this thread, but i think some more constructive feedback could be given when rating peoples photographs.

mb_, it's a nice picture overall, but could have used a more interesting sky with clouds. Your horizon is a bit slanted to the left. Also, there is alot of sky and greens. Maybe zoom in a bit more to pick out some details in the scene. Overall: 7/10.

http://farm7.staticflickr.com/6109/6...2b3df1e5_b.jpg