REVscene Automotive Forum

REVscene Automotive Forum (https://www.revscene.net/forums/)
-   Vancouver Auto Chat (https://www.revscene.net/forums/vancouver-auto-chat_173/)
-   -   Should I sell my car? (https://www.revscene.net/forums/696255-should-i-sell-my-car.html)

The_AK 06-25-2014 07:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by multicartual (Post 8493266)
I dream of the day Vancouverites, sick of transit and the high cost of car maintenance, are all rumbling down Cambie street in a sea of European luxury cars powered by cheap American V8's

I can imagine what the reverse would be like... the styling of american cars with the cost of maintenance like european...

godwin 06-25-2014 09:46 PM

Mass market cars are horrible investments.

I agree with the sentiment, just trade for a newer car eg Honda accord. Problem solved.

Quote:

Originally Posted by rzrshrp (Post 8492842)
@LP700-4: Yeah I think we should be fine financially. There is always a loss to be had with investments like these. It's just that I don't know if there is a point in keeping the car, in case I rebuild the transmission and the new one craps out again as well.


xpl0sive 06-25-2014 09:52 PM

a buddy of mine is in the market for a 2004-2005 TL right now... PM me some details about the car and some pics if you have them...

underscore 06-26-2014 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by franko (Post 8493146)
It's the third gear clutch that goes, which sends material all through the transmission. If it hasn't been replaced with the updated 2005 part it 100% will fail. To get it rebuilt is minimum $2500. Yes other cars may have issues, but this one will have issues, and a very expensive one at that. Any TL without it done knock $3k off whatever they're asking. I know as a relative bought one new.

Makes sense, like I said it was a quick search. I'd either start saving up for the fix if you love the car, or get rid of it now and get something else before it becomes problematic.

fsy82 06-26-2014 11:11 AM

Is it your car or your mommy's car? Cause if its your car than do what you want with it. But my assumption is that its not your car and you pretend it is.

Gumby 06-26-2014 11:21 AM

How do you guys know that car x is known for problem y?

Gucci Mane 06-26-2014 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by underscore (Post 8493069)
A quick search lead me to some info mentioning that regularly changing the fluid and the pressure switches will prevent/correct tranny issues, so that may be worth digging into. Like others have said, getting a different car is a whole new can of worms, even a brand new vehicle could have the same defects down the road.



People still buy 97-01 Prelude autos for the same price as manuals.

Quote:

Originally Posted by franko (Post 8493146)
It's the third gear clutch that goes, which sends material all through the transmission. If it hasn't been replaced with the updated 2005 part it 100% will fail. To get it rebuilt is minimum $2500. Yes other cars may have issues, but this one will have issues, and a very expensive one at that. Any TL without it done knock $3k off whatever they're asking. I know as a relative bought one new.

no fluid changes or pressure switches will fix the problem. its a design flaw with the trans from honda. the second gear clutch packs do not receive enough lubrication and with time they obviously wear to nothing leaving nice little floaty bits floating around in the trans oil. honda at one point tried to remedy the problem with an oil jet but people were still having problems. its just best to stay away from the cars that have this transmission. i've owned 2 TL's with this trans. the first one i didnt have an issue with and ended up trading it in with 150k on it. the second one had the trans replaced at 80K and it was fine when i traded it in for my pickup.

Quote:

Originally Posted by fsy82 (Post 8493624)
Is your car or your mommy's car? Cause if its your car than do what you want with it. But my assumption is that its not your car and you pretend it is.

agreed. OP if its a car you purchased dont listen to your parents. i made that mistake once and i will never do it again. buy whatever the hell you want. my dad trapped me with the same bullshit about needing to have a car with auto because they need to be able to drive it as well. to this day i have still never owned a car with a manual trans and i fucking regret it big time.

fsy82 06-26-2014 01:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gumby (Post 8493630)
How do you guys know that car x is known for problem y?

Its a common problem during the period when Chrysler was making the tiptronic transmissions for Honda/Acura.

freakshow 06-26-2014 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Knight_KB (Post 8493631)
agreed. OP if its a car you purchased dont listen to your parents. i made that mistake once and i will never do it again. buy whatever the hell you want. my dad trapped me with the same bullshit about needing to have a car with auto because they need to be able to drive it as well. to this day i have still never owned a car with a manual trans and i fucking regret it big time.

Do you realize how stupid this sounds?

I hope your dad calls you up and says
i made that mistake (you) once and i will never do it again. buy whatever the hell you want. my kid trapped me with the same bullshit about needing to have a house/diapers/food/education/activities/toys. to this day i have still never owned a what i really want and i fucking regret it big time.

it's your damn parents who cared for you your whole life..

underscore 06-26-2014 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gumby (Post 8493630)
How do you guys know that car x is known for problem y?

Searching on the internet for common problems, I use it before I buy anything. Unfortunately most people don't do that and their family ends up doing a shitload of work to help them fix problems they should've avoided in the first place.



...I swear I'm not bitter.

Gucci Mane 06-26-2014 10:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freakshow (Post 8493688)
Do you realize how stupid this sounds?

I hope your dad calls you up and says
i made that mistake (you) once and i will never do it again. buy whatever the hell you want. my kid trapped me with the same bullshit about needing to have a house/diapers/food/education/activities/toys. to this day i have still never owned a what i really want and i fucking regret it big time.

it's your damn parents who cared for you your whole life..

not going to respond to this because its kind of personal.

rzrshrp 06-26-2014 11:47 PM

What's with the hate? I never said it was my car. In the whole OP it says "our" or "we" when referring to the car. I am simply just trying to help out my family so they don't have to deal with extra headaches b/c of a car I suggested them to buy.

I'm not trying to prove anything to anyone by "pretending" it's my car.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Knight_KB (Post 8493631)
no fluid changes or pressure switches will fix the problem. its a design flaw with the trans from honda. the second gear clutch packs do not receive enough lubrication and with time they obviously wear to nothing leaving nice little floaty bits floating around in the trans oil. honda at one point tried to remedy the problem with an oil jet but people were still having problems. its just best to stay away from the cars that have this transmission. i've owned 2 TL's with this trans. the first one i didnt have an issue with and ended up trading it in with 150k on it. the second one had the trans replaced at 80K and it was fine when i traded it in for my pickup.

So what do I tell the dude at the dealership to replace, if I just want to fix it? Do I replace the whole transmission right now or what? I don't want to be scammed by them so I'm asking you haha, they suggest all these useless things. It's scary how they go any time, makes me think of my mom or someone being stranded somewhere because of it. Pretty dangerous.

LP700-4 06-26-2014 11:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rzrshrp (Post 8494005)
So what do I tell the dude at the dealership to replace, if I just want to fix it? Do I replace the whole transmission right now or what? I don't want to be scammed by them so I'm asking you haha, they suggest all these useless things. It's scary how they go any time, makes me think of my mom or someone being stranded somewhere because of it. Pretty dangerous.

Nothing you do will "fix" it. With these its almost like a wear and tear thing. Once it goes, rebuilt it, drive it, then repeat.

Frequent fluid changes and pressure switches might prolong the life a bit but ultimately will need a rebuild. Usually the transmissions start to slip and jerk first before they completely go. Not anything dangerous.

Honestly if you really like the TL that much and would like to drive it for a long time then just save up for a rebuild somewhere down the line. All cars are gonna have some sort of issues eventually from what ive found. Even the type s

underscore 06-27-2014 08:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rzrshrp (Post 8494005)
It's scary how they go any time, makes me think of my mom or someone being stranded somewhere because of it. Pretty dangerous.

It *shouldn't* just suddenly explode, there are usually warning signs. I'd get Acura to look up your VIN for all possible recalls though. If you're worried, get your mom BCAA roadside assistance or something.

And don't change the tranny until it starts having problems. They never fixed the design flaw so even a refurbished tranny will fail, I've found several ways people have tried to prolong the life of the tranny but nothing conclusive.

BrRsn 06-27-2014 08:34 AM

Yep .. everything's a band-aid fix.

I drained + refilled and the shifts would smoothen out, then a couple of weeks go by and it's the same old problem with the shift from 1st --> 2nd(my car's got 230,000 km on it at the moment, so it's ready to go anytime basically -- fingers crossed it lasts awhile longer but I'm doubtful)

thumper 06-27-2014 08:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by underscore (Post 8494095)
It *shouldn't* just suddenly explode, there are usually warning signs. I'd get Acura to look up your VIN for all possible recalls though. If you're worried, get your mom BCAA roadside assistance or something.

And don't change the tranny until it starts having problems. They never fixed the design flaw so even a refurbished tranny will fail, I've found several ways people have tried to prolong the life of the tranny but nothing conclusive.

my friend's transmission did not "explode" per se, but there wasn't really any advanced warning. he had a few rough shifts on occasion which he brought up in his last few dealer services, but the mechanics were not able to replicate it, and i do not recall them doing any fluid changes. then the day came when there was some shuddering from the transmission under acceleration on the highway and then it started slipping hard and that was it.

keep in mind this happened roughly back in 2008 i think, and my friend is not from here (san francisco). i can't remember if this was before or after the class action lawsuits started to fly.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:25 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.
Revscene.net cannot be held accountable for the actions of its members nor does the opinions of the members represent that of Revscene.net