REVscene - Vancouver Automotive Forum

Jobo · 08-07-2009, 11:39 AM

My sister was driving my car for some errands and she got pulled over for doing a rolling stop on kingsway and patterson (where the yield is). She got a 167 dollar ticket. I was wondering, am i at all affected by this? since the car is under my name?

thanks

zulutango · 08-07-2009, 12:02 PM

The only way you get into trouble is if you let her drive your car again and she gets hit while running another stop sign...then your insurance pays for it. Unless the VT is issued as "registered owner" and you are the owner and agree to take her ticket, your driving record cannot suffer...and an "RO" ticket comes with no points. You got off clean this time.

Jobo · 08-07-2009, 12:08 PM

thanks alot for clearing it up

wing_woo · 08-07-2009, 02:45 PM

I see officers there looking for people doing that. They stand behind the green electrical box. It's funny, I saw them kind of tiptoeing to look over the box to see if anyone did not come to a complete stop.

Blinky · 08-07-2009, 06:47 PM

Uh, WTH?

Ticket for a "rolling stop" on a Yield? As I understand, there's no need to stop on a Yield sign. I'm not going to demonize the police, but you might want to examine that ticket.

Eff-1 · 08-07-2009, 07:17 PM

Exactly. As far as I know, you can roll through a yield sign.

E=mc² · 08-07-2009, 07:34 PM

^that's exactly what I was thinking
though I didn't wanna post for fear that there's something I'm missing about yield signs.

Perhaps it was a case where there were enough cars that warrants a stop but the guy didn't stop completely and just blew into the gap? Even then that sounds weird to me..

on my class 5 road test to get onto the highway there was a yield sign but since there were no cars I didn't stop and wasn't penalized..

then again I missed a school zone and wasn't penalized

zulutango · 08-08-2009, 06:39 AM

OK....didn't think this was that confusing.....YIELD.....you continue driving and YIELD to any traffic.....STOP....a complete cessation of forward movement. Then move forward when it is clear and continue driving. The STOP must be done at or BEFORE the stop line/crosswalk/sidewalk/intersecting curb, depending what is there. The actual stop sign is not where you stop, it simply orders you to stop.

E=mc² · 08-08-2009, 09:42 AM

^
But as you said, "yield" means you continue driving and yield to traffic. There's no requirement to stop.

Then I guess the ticket was for not stopping at the stop line (assuming traffic was heavy and so one has no choice but to stop), but rolling through it and then stopped PAST the stop line?

that makes sense I guess

*EDIT*
there are NO stop lines for yield signs. Only potentially pedestrian crosswalks. There's no requirement to stop before the crosswalk if there are no pedestrians unless it's at an intersection with a red light, in which case you can't block the crosswalk.
So I can't see how you can get a rolling stop infraction for yield signs.

Quicksilver · 08-08-2009, 11:21 AM

there are 2 types of yeilds. A red yield and a green yield. A green yield (one facing a green light, or a yield sign with no lights present) means you can roll through and yield to any traffic present. A red yield (one facing a red light) means you must come to a complete stop, check for traffic, then proceed. I'm not familiar with the area this ticket was received, but if there's a light, then a right turn lane with an island and a yield sign on it, if the light was red, and she didn't stop before proceeding, then the ticket is valid.

zulutango · 08-08-2009, 01:42 PM

"186 Except when a peace officer directs otherwise, if there is a stop sign at an intersection, a driver of a vehicle must stop

(a) at the marked stop line, if any,

(b) before entering the marked crosswalk on the near side of the intersection, or

(c) when there is neither a marked crosswalk nor a stop line, before entering the intersection, at the point nearest the intersecting highway from which the driver has a view of approaching traffic on the intersecting highway. "

It's simple...IF she did this, the ticket is not valid...if she did NOT, then the ticket IS valid.

Blinky · 08-08-2009, 02:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jobo

My sister was driving my car for some errands and she got pulled over for doing a rolling stop on kingsway and patterson (where the yield is). She got a 167 dollar ticket. I was wondering, am i at all affected by this? since the car is under my name?

thanks

Zulu,

The question/issue I have have about the original post is highlighted. Apparently it wasn't a stop sign.

Incidentally...

Per schedule 1 Signs of the MVA (http://www.bclaws.ca/Recon/document/...s/26_58_06.xml)

Quote:

STOP (Regulatory)
Come to a complete stop and only proceed when it is safe to do so.

YIELD (Regulatory)
Yield the right of way to all other traffic, stopping if necessary.

...so if it was a yield sign and not a stop sign I can't see how a ticket would be justified.

E=mc² · 08-08-2009, 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zulutango

"186 Except when a peace officer directs otherwise, if there is a stop sign at an intersection, a driver of a vehicle must stop

(a) at the marked stop line, if any,

(b) before entering the marked crosswalk on the near side of the intersection, or

(c) when there is neither a marked crosswalk nor a stop line, before entering the intersection, at the point nearest the intersecting highway from which the driver has a view of approaching traffic on the intersecting highway. "

It's simple...IF she did this, the ticket is not valid...if she did NOT, then the ticket IS valid.

But this isn't a stop sign, it's a yield sign.
It's one of those right turns where, theres a little turn off on the right with a yield sign. This is NOT the same as facing a red light or stop sign.
This is where I'm confused, because I'm sure there's no requirement to stop behind the stop line (in fact, there IS NO stop line) if the latter condition "stopping if necessary" was in play.

SOMETIMES however, there are zebra crossings for pedestrians, but if there are no pedestrians theres no requirement to stop behind the crosswalk (you don't stop at pedestrian crosswalks if there are no pedestrians after all). Most people stop PAST the crosswalk near the merge point. How on earth can you get a rolling stop infraction for yield signs??
The only time you are required to stop before the crosswalk is when you're at a stop sign or red light.

I take back what I said in my last post. I don't see how this ticket can be valid.

zulutango · 08-08-2009, 04:18 PM

As you re-posted my post above...if there was NO stop sign, then the ticket for not stopping at a stop sign canot be valid. Time for a disclosure request and some photographs of the intersection.

E=mc² · 08-08-2009, 04:53 PM

^
lol I think I was just confused by your wording

wing_woo · 08-09-2009, 09:37 AM

If it's the one where you merge onto Kingsway from Grange St (it's the only place I know near Kingsway and Patterson that you merge onto Kingsway), then there is a stop sign right before the yield sign. That's what I was talking about. A lot of people miss that stop sign there and that's the place where cops hide behind the green electrical box and watch cars that don't come to a complete stop before creeping forward to try to merge.

zulutango · 08-09-2009, 09:47 AM

So they miss the stop sign that they see first, but see the yield sign which is past it? Go figure??

Blinky · 08-09-2009, 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zulutango

So they miss the stop sign that they see first, but see the yield sign which is past it? Go figure??

Since when does a stop sign mean "Stop" to your average driver?

Yield just means they don't even think about stopping!

zulutango · 08-10-2009, 05:24 AM

'STOP' means
S top T o O ther P eople...not me????

Soundy · 08-10-2009, 06:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wing_woo

If it's the one where you merge onto Kingsway from Grange St (it's the only place I know near Kingsway and Patterson that you merge onto Kingsway), then there is a stop sign right before the yield sign. That's what I was talking about. A lot of people miss that stop sign there and that's the place where cops hide behind the green electrical box and watch cars that don't come to a complete stop before creeping forward to try to merge.

That's the one I was thinking of, too... I think when the OP said "where the yield is" he meant "where the merge is". There's been a stop sign there for at least 20 years... I don't recall there being a yield sign AFTER that.

wing_woo · 08-10-2009, 08:18 AM

Not sure if there is a yield sign either, but I know the stop sign is there for sure. Lots of people (I've been guilty of it before too) but when you see the coast is clear, you want to gun it onto Kingsway before the cars come. Several times, I see the cars coming and if I stop at the Stop sign there, then I will not be able to make the merge and would have to wait till all the cars pass. I really hate that part. After seeing the enforcement there, I just do not go there anymore and if I do have to go that way, I just come to a complete stop and ignore the idiots behind that honk me. Usually, I'd go the longer way and get onto Kingsway before Patterson so I don't need to merge onto Kingsway from Grange.