I'm
pretty sure you can just get any NVIDIA card from the same series. Remember you do
not want SLI or Crossfire here, just 2 video cards.
Or it could be that you need an identical card. I'm not sure, since I have never run multiple graphics cards outside SLI or Crossfire. If the hardware and drivers support it, it shouldn't matter that you're using an Intel chipset. If there are enough PCI-E lanes, it should work in theory.
Best bet would be to borrow a GeForce and give it a try