Senna4ever | 04-09-2010 12:48 AM | Quote:
Originally Posted by SkinnyPupp
(Post 6899214)
No offense, but it sounds like you are buying into corporate spiel ;)
Either that or you're not explaining it very well to me
Call it 'pixel level' or 'underlying math' it's all the same. If you open a JPG in Photoshop, you are just working on a bitmap that has to be compressed again when you save it. | No, it's not corporate spiel, and it's not the same. They explained technical things that were way over my head in many parts. I wish I could explain it better...I'm a photographic geek, not a computer geek. Photoshop works on the pixels, the image that you see on the screen by re-arranging them, changing colour, etc. Capture One & Lightroom work on the level below the pixels. The image you see on the screen while working in Capture One or Lightroom is not the final image - its a rendering of the math that they are working with. When you save the image as a PSD, TIFF, JPEG, etc, then it renders the math into pixels. Capture One and Lightroom are far superior to Photoshop regarding colour management due to the way they work on the image. You can do things in seconds that would take hours in Photoshop - I'd have to show you. On the flipside, Capture One and Lightroom can't do the higher level edits like utilizing layers. I use Lightroom for digital asset management and low level edits & colour management, Capture One Pro 5 for more intense colour management & edits that would simply take too long to do in Photoshop, and Photoshop for high level editing that neither Capture One and Lightroom can do. I find that Lightroom is good enough for wedding photography work, but fashion and commercial images will frequently need the functions found in Capture One and Photohshop. None of the programs are meant to replace each other - you just get the ones you need for your particular line of work, although Capture One is one of the best RAW converters on the market.
A bit off topic, but if you want fast RAW conversions, Photo Mechanic can't be beat. It's by far the fastest RAW conversion software and the most comprehensive metadata tagging program on the market. |