REVscene Automotive Forum

REVscene Automotive Forum (https://www.revscene.net/forums/)
-   Vancouver Auto Chat (https://www.revscene.net/forums/vancouver-auto-chat_173/)
-   -   Front lip fell off on hwy, installed by Lotus Autobody.. (https://www.revscene.net/forums/680726-front-lip-fell-off-hwy-installed-lotus-autobody.html)

freakshow 02-20-2013 11:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snails (Post 8165068)
put simply,if you want it done right,do it yourself, me and my friends do all the work on our cars

Easy to say if you *can* do it all. But if you can't, then it's a matter of you get what you pay for.

snails 02-20-2013 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freakshow (Post 8165076)
Easy to say if you *can* do it all. But if you can't, then it's a matter of you get what you pay for.


you would be surprised how quick you learn when you start doing something, we arnt talking about building an engine here.

it never hurts to ask for some help either, a while back some of you may remember a girl on the forum asking for help with where to get an oil change because she didnt know how, i pm'd her had her bring everything i listed and showed her everything from jacking a car up to the filling and didnt even charge her for it, now she knows how all cuz someone felt like helping.


just a thought

monkeywrench 02-20-2013 11:40 AM

Not to be harsh but it is a bit mind boggling why anyone would bring their car to a shop like that. I know of a $200,000 car that went to that shop for repairs when clearly they have no idea how to repair anything on it.

?NR 02-20-2013 12:00 PM

is this the same Andrew from the old Park Collision?
Posted via RS Mobile

Yodamaster 02-20-2013 12:10 PM

I'll never understand why people use double sided tape as the main method to install body panels. If you are planning on having a lip installed for a long period of time, it would be best to make sure that the install is permanent.

That being said, screws and double sided tape are not the best options out there, even rivets would be better suited to this kind of part. The most reliable way of fastening a part to a bumper (and still being able to take it off) would have to be properly sized bolts, nuts, and washers along the length of the lip. Double sided tape should be used to make sure chafing doesn't happen between the upper portions of the lip and the bumper, as it did on yours, not to hold it on.

Unless you told them to only use double sided tape, they should have used an alternate method of installing the lip, running two screws at either end is fucking idiotic. Seeing that your lip mounting point is at the very bottom, rivets would have been a far more secure way of attaching it without having bolt heads sticking out from under the bumper.

E60_M5 02-20-2013 12:25 PM

If you get another lip, I would recommend using double sided tape to hold the front lip onto the bumper where you want it. Then using a chaulking gun fill the underside of the lip where it meets the bumper with urethane adhesive every 12 inch or so. This is a permanent bond and if you want to remove it later on, your bumper will have to be sanded down by a bodyshop and refinished.

Again, the double sided tape is only used so that the lip doesnt move around while the urethane cures up.

You can get this urethane at Lordco.
Welcome to Pro Form Products

jpark 02-20-2013 12:26 PM

i have 8 screws holding up my lip, and i am about same ride height as you, or might be even lower

no problems so far, sounds like a lack of screws caused this.. sorry to hear :/

asr 02-20-2013 12:35 PM

@limitless: If you have any difficulty to install the lip on, I can help you out at your place with my tools. Also fixing the cf is not easy, it is pretty hard to let the fiber glass stay on with the cf. Also you need higher sand grip paper to sand all the reinforce plastic and clear coat completely.

Limitless 02-20-2013 12:48 PM

@snails I want to, especially if it saves me money lol. I
The only reason I dropped it off at a shop is because I wasn't comfortablr with drilling into carbon fiber, and the rear had to be painted so I thought why not get the sides installed too while I was at it. I put too much money into just the front lip, so this time I think I'm just going to try to install it myself to save money

@vr6 Yes I believe hes the manager

@monkeywrench I agree. I heard nothing about the shop when I left my car there except for my one friends good experiencegrtting his lip iinstalled there, except now his bumper is scratched as well like mine. Lotus was working on a lambo when I dropped my car off so thst only gave me an even bigger false sense or security

@NR! Im not sure
Posted via RS Mobile

Limitless 02-20-2013 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yodamaster (Post 8165122)
I'll never understand why people use double sided tape as the main method to install body panels. If you are planning on having a lip installed for a long period of time, it would be best to make sure that the install is permanent.

That being said, screws and double sided tape are not the best options out there, even rivets would be better suited to this kind of part. The most reliable way of fastening a part to a bumper (and still being able to take it off) would have to be properly sized bolts, nuts, and washers along the length of the lip. Double sided tape should be used to make sure chafing doesn't happen between the upper portions of the lip and the bumper, as it did on yours, not to hold it on.

Unless you told them to only use double sided tape, they should have used an alternate method of installing the lip, running two screws at either end is fucking idiotic. Seeing that your lip mounting point is at the very bottom, rivets would have been a far more secure way of attaching it without having bolt heads sticking out from under the bumper.

I would much rather have my lip installed permanently if it meant that it would not lead to it falling off on the hwy. I'll look into that, thank you. I agree it was very idiotic, and that Andrew actually believes it was an okay way to mount it even after my lip fell off...

Quote:

Originally Posted by E60_M5 (Post 8165130)
If you get another lip, I would recommend using double sided tape to hold the front lip onto the bumper where you want it. Then using a chaulking gun fill the underside of the lip where it meets the bumper with urethane adhesive every 12 inch or so. This is a permanent bond and if you want to remove it later on, your bumper will have to be sanded down by a bodyshop and refinished.

Again, the double sided tape is only used so that the lip doesnt move around while the urethane cures up.

You can get this urethane at Lordco.
Welcome to Pro Form Products

I'll look into this as well, thanks!

Quote:

Originally Posted by jpark (Post 8165131)
i have 8 screws holding up my lip, and i am about same ride height as you, or might be even lower

no problems so far, sounds like a lack of screws caused this.. sorry to hear :/

Yup, definitely lack of screws imo..

Quote:

Originally Posted by asr (Post 8165135)
@limitless: If you have any difficulty to install the lip on, I can help you out at your place with my tools. Also fixing the cf is not easy, it is pretty hard to let the fiber glass stay on with the cf. Also you need higher sand grip paper to sand all the reinforce plastic and clear coat completely.

Thanks, I'll shoot you a PM later if I have trouble installing it! Agh really.. I hope everything goes okay with the repair sigh. My friend is going to be doing most of the work and I'm just going to be helping out and learning along the way

dared3vil0 02-20-2013 01:20 PM

Limitless, I had a couple good experiences with a body shop in burnaby, I know it's a long drive for you , But pm me if you want more info.

mx5nate 02-20-2013 01:54 PM

He doesn't live in richmond. It won't be much of a drive for him.
Posted via RS Mobile

falcon 02-20-2013 03:04 PM

So I skimmed the post because i didn't feel like reading an essay but from the jist of it, you saw problems from the get go, and didn't bring it up and do something about it? Falls off months later? No one to blame but yourself. I would have brought the issue up immediately and dealt with the manager. The rub marks are of course going to happen when you install a lip on your bumper. It's happened to my cars before and it's part of adding something to a painted surface. Unless the entire lip was bolted/glued on it will rub like that, and let me guess if they would have bolted it on with more hardware/glue, you'd be mad that they glued onto your paint, right?

monkeywrench 02-20-2013 03:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by !NR (Post 8165114)
is this the same Andrew from the old Park Collision?
Posted via RS Mobile

That is correct

inv4zn 02-20-2013 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by falcon (Post 8165243)
So I skimmed the post because i didn't feel like reading an essay but from the jist of it, you saw problems from the get go, and didn't bring it up and do something about it? Falls off months later? No one to blame but yourself. I would have brought the issue up immediately and dealt with the manager. The rub marks are of course going to happen when you install a lip on your bumper. It's happened to my cars before and it's part of adding something to a painted surface. Unless the entire lip was bolted/glued on it will rub like that, and let me guess if they would have bolted it on with more hardware/glue, you'd be mad that they glued onto your paint, right?

So, by your logic, if you hired and paid a professional to do a job for you because you weren't sure you could do it yourself, and he reassured you that he did a good job, it'll be completely your fault when it turns out he actually did a terrible job? And you'd have nobody to blame but yourself when he refuses to take even the slightest bit of responsibility and pride for his workmanship?

:fulloffuck: wtf?

The point is the shop told him it was ok. Because the OP went there, to do a job for him that he couldn't do. That's like me blaming you for going to a bad doctor when you couldn't diagnose yourself.

Get off his back.

snails 02-20-2013 03:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by falcon (Post 8165243)
So I skimmed the post because i didn't feel like reading an essay but from the jist of it, you saw problems from the get go, and didn't bring it up and do something about it? Falls off months later? No one to blame but yourself. I would have brought the issue up immediately and dealt with the manager. The rub marks are of course going to happen when you install a lip on your bumper. It's happened to my cars before and it's part of adding something to a painted surface. Unless the entire lip was bolted/glued on it will rub like that, and let me guess if they would have bolted it on with more hardware/glue, you'd be mad that they glued onto your paint, right?


wait... so he paid someone to mount it... it shouldn't have started to come off in the first place, he brought it back with concern and he was sent on his way... that dosnt sound like his fault, if it was done right the first time, it wouldn't come off in the first place :suspicious:

Holeshot 02-20-2013 04:52 PM

lack of screws, lack of tape, lack of skills for install, lack of time for install, and a lip that doesn't fit well.
a bad combo. some bodyshops will not install aftermarket bodykits or they will but will not guarentee it due to quality and fit of the parts.
Ive install a few ground FX from Roush on to Mustangs and they fit perfect and ive never had one fall off or scratch the bumper like yours did.
You get what you pay for.

StylinRed 02-20-2013 06:43 PM

Im kind of with Falcon here


Quote:

The day I went to go pick up my car after the kit had been installed, I noticed things wrong with every single piece.
he noticed problems from the get go but didn't do anything about it he bares some responsibility


Having said that though a shop should be responsible for it's work, after all that's their bread and butter and most of all their namesake and as we know your name is everything (chris dorner)

prelude_prince 02-20-2013 07:03 PM

If this is in fact Andrew from the old Park Collision. I don't know what to say.

I myself had quite a lot of work done on a few cars from Andrew and Tommy back at Park Collision days (5+ years ago) and the jobs were all very well done, even after many years I didn't notice any shoddy work and I had no complaints.

monkeywrench 02-20-2013 08:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by prelude_prince (Post 8165436)
If this is in fact Andrew from the old Park Collision. I don't know what to say.

I myself had quite a lot of work done on a few cars from Andrew and Tommy back at Park Collision days (5+ years ago) and the jobs were all very well done, even after many years I didn't notice any shoddy work and I had no complaints.

I've never dealt with him personally but from stories I hear, it seems that every shop he's been working at, has been brought down and closed since he's been employed. I believe he used to be at Hugh auto body before as well.

Funny enough, I've been told he doesn't get complaints either

jing 02-20-2013 09:03 PM

My lip is held on by about 8 screws and it's nearly come off a few times. Not from scraping or anything though, more so unavoidable road debris
Posted via RS Mobile

prelude_prince 02-20-2013 09:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by monkeywrench (Post 8165516)
I've never dealt with him personally but from stories I hear, it seems that every shop he's been working at, has been brought down and closed since he's been employed. I believe he used to be at Hugh auto body before as well.

Funny enough, I've been told he doesn't get complaints either

Ouch. Yeah I've been out of the scene in Van. Only dealt with Andrew back at Park Collision, and yeah as stated, had no troubles like OP is having (my cars and some friends whom I refered to). I've been fuc ked over by some shops before and I always make it my motion to let people around me know their shit practices so they don't get fucked over as well. I have quite a lot of dirt on some places muahaha. But Andrew was always cool to me so I actually refered friends and family there often.

Also I never confirmed it but I always assumed Andrew was part-owner back at Park.

SkunkWorks 02-20-2013 09:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by melloman (Post 8164926)
When I had someone TRY to break into my Audi and completely fuck up my door handle/key hole.. All work was done by "Donn Dean Collision" in Burnaby. I actually signed papers that guaranteed ALL work for the lifetime of the car. So if the door started to even sag/squeak or anything, I could take it back.

On the contrary, I had quite a negative experience at Donn Dean. Ended up having to bring the car back multiple times for paint runs, missed sections of clear coat, and dust/dirt in the paint. Yes they redid the issues when I pointed them out, but you would think they'd look over their work before handing the keys and have a certain quality they'd adhere to after multiple returns. Haven't been back since.

http://www.revscene.net/forums/53313...shop-woes.html

Limitless 02-20-2013 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by StylinRed (Post 8165421)
Im kind of with Falcon here




he noticed problems from the get go but didn't do anything about it he bares some responsibility.


Having said that though a shop should be responsible for it's work, after all that's their bread and butter and most of all their namesake and as we know your name is everything (chris dorner)

I did tell him everything that i had an issue with but other than siliconing the rear spats he wasn't willing to fix anything else, becsuse he didnt find any of those issues i had poined out to be a legitimate problem in his eyes, no matter how I put it. I didnt aggressively force him to fix anything but i did express how unhappy i was. Only reason i didnt force him was because i thought that if we had a good relationship then he woulf be more willing to fix any problems that came up later
But apparently not
Posted via RS Mobile

Lomac 02-20-2013 09:59 PM

Just to play devil's advocate here... Three months after installing a front lip, I'm surprised at any shop that would offer any sort of guarantee on it. To look at it from the shop's point of view, you could have hung the lip on a concrete barrier while parking and ripped the screws part way out in the process. This could have caused the lip to fall off while at speed. (Hell, I don't even have a front lip on my car and my front bumper rubs on pretty much everything I come across. I'm positive any sort of lip I'd put on would be torn off within a week. :lol)

BTW, I'm not saying this happened; it's merely a view that a body shop may take.

It's one thing to warranty body work or a paint job as it's pretty easy to tell when something is a result of poor workmanship or from the driver's lack of judgment. However, a front lip is subject to a lot of things and can be easily affected by the smallest of them all.


That said, two screws and a patch of 3M tape does seem a little sketchy...


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 09:22 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.
Revscene.net cannot be held accountable for the actions of its members nor does the opinions of the members represent that of Revscene.net