REVscene Automotive Forum

REVscene Automotive Forum (https://www.revscene.net/forums/)
-   Vancouver Auto Chat (https://www.revscene.net/forums/vancouver-auto-chat_173/)
-   -   Family sues Tesla for being too fast....... (https://www.revscene.net/forums/715765-family-sues-tesla-being-too-fast.html)

originalhypa 01-10-2019 11:50 AM

Family sues Tesla for being too fast.......
 
After their 18 year old son was killed in an accident.

https://postmediadriving.files.wordp...0&h=370&crop=1

Quote:

Family sues Tesla for too-fast car after son dies in Model S collision

The electric sedan was being driven by a friend at 186 km/h in a 50-km/h zone when it hit a wall and burst into flames

Edgar Monserratt Martinez was riding in the front passenger seat of a Tesla Model S driven by his friend Barrett Riley, also 18, when Riley lost control at 186 km/h (116 mph), crashing and killing both young men May 8, 2018.

Martinez’s parents are suing Tesla, alleging the vehicle shouldn’t have been able to drive at such a high speed, and that the car shouldn’t have caught fire as quickly as it did after the collision.

The Tesla was apparently supposed to have a 135-km/h limiter activated; the governor had been installed by Tesla mechanics at Riley’s parents’ request after Riley was caught speeding through an 80-km/h zone at a blistering 180 km/h.

However, the limiter was allegedly removed without the consent of the Riley family during routine service, shortly after it was installed.

https://driving.ca/tesla/auto-news/n...el-s-collision

Clickbait title says one thing, but the truth is that the parents should have put the lockdown on the kid. Responsibility starts at home, and while it's hard to be a parent sometimes, I'd rather have my kid upset than dead.

Rip

320icar 01-10-2019 12:01 PM

LLOOOOOLLLL

Scotsman 01-10-2019 12:25 PM

At least they didn't kill innocent people

Darwinism

Zedbra 01-10-2019 12:40 PM

Interesting times we live in when you can act like an idiot, then sue someone for your stupidity. Eventually, someone will put a hard stop to entitlement and reality will settle in; unfortunately for this family, their son's life was the brass tax to be paid.

Dragon-88 01-10-2019 12:42 PM

Still would've been alive if they bought him a Nissan Leaf, no friends would've wanted to drive it. No speed limits would've been broken.

hud 91gt 01-10-2019 01:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scotsman (Post 8935234)
At least they didn't kill innocent people

Darwinism

He did. The passenger.

Feel awful for the parents of the passenger. The drivers parents though.... I would have never been allowed to drive their car again. So I’d just speed in my Escort. Lol.

Bouncing Bettys 01-10-2019 01:04 PM

It might have been as simple as a factory reset which removed the limiter and was missed by technicians. The owner's might not have realized that it could be so easy to remove it, thus why they didn't make note of it before the service or ensure it was still in place after. Tragic results, but it could lead to better safeguards in the industry.

My parents never had the money or the technology of today to simply program a speed limiter, they just bought me the slowest car they could find.

Jmac 01-10-2019 01:12 PM

The suit claims a Tesla tech removed the speed limiter without their knowledge, Tesla’s batteries are unsafe, and Tesla did not make use of a patent that would have limited the spread of the battery fire.

Regardless, play stupid games, win stupid prizes. While I have empathy for the families involved, it doesn’t excuse the fact he was going nearly 4x the speed limit.

Koflach 01-10-2019 01:29 PM

My Model 3 has the ability to limit the speed of the car via the app anywhere from 80-140km/h. Not sure if the S has the same feature but it's a great way to lock down how fast you can go in the 3

Great68 01-10-2019 01:35 PM

Did no one properly read the article?

The parents of the passenger who died were the ones who owned the car. The kid's friend was the one driving.

Bouncing Bettys 01-10-2019 01:42 PM

Years before I was old enough to drive, I thought how great it would be to have speed limit signs equipped with a signal which would automatically limit your vehicle's speed as you came within range of it. Pretty draconian looking back at it, but very effective.

320icar 01-10-2019 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Great68 (Post 8935251)
Did no one properly read the article?

The parents of the passenger who died were the ones who owned the car. The kid's friend was the one driving.

We read it. So there are two dumb 18 year olds. Not much changes from my first comment. Just like hobo’s dying in donation bins, I have zero sympathy

white rocket 01-10-2019 02:04 PM

18 year old kid gets busted doing 100kph over the limit and the parents solution is to put a speed governor in and give the car back? Parenting 101 right there FailFish

denham 01-10-2019 02:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon-88 (Post 8935240)
Still would've been alive if they bought him a Nissan Leaf, no friends would've wanted to drive it. No speed limits would've been broken.

Exactly. Even with a speed limiter I wouldn't trust my kid with a Tesla. Honestly knowing how I drove when I was 18 I probably wouldn't trust them with any car, but a Leaf would definitely be better.

AzNightmare 01-10-2019 02:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bouncing Bettys (Post 8935253)
Years before I was old enough to drive, I thought how great it would be to have speed limit signs equipped with a signal which would automatically limit your vehicle's speed as you came within range of it. Pretty draconian looking back at it, but very effective.

I've always found it kind of silly that people need a sign to tell them how fast they should go. I guess in the ideal world, people would just figure out when too fast is too fast for their own good.

It's all about picking your spots and driving according to the situation and road conditions. But I guess that requires a certain about of awareness.

There's really never a good time to be speeding excessively by that much though.

Berzerker 01-10-2019 02:27 PM

Poor Tesla :*(

Berz out.

denham 01-10-2019 02:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AzNightmare (Post 8935263)
I've always found it kind of silly that people need a sign to tell them how fast they should go. I guess in the ideal world, people would just figure out when too fast is too fast for their own good.

It's all about picking your spots and driving according to the situation and road conditions. But I guess that requires a certain about of awareness.

There's really never a good time to be speeding excessively by that much though.

I totally agree but I think 1) some people are totally clueless as to what's safe and 2) some people just don't give a shit or think they're such good drivers that they can go faster than is actually safe. If everyone was like you maybe it would work, but really they're not.

you! 01-10-2019 03:01 PM

hahahahaha what a bunch of idiots LOL

Hondaracer 01-10-2019 03:02 PM

The Model S is a fast ducking far and I only drove the P80 or whatever the mid range model is. The braking etc and taking your foot off the gas also feels completely different than a regular vehicle so I’m sure going 180 is borderline out of control regardless of the circumstances

Bouncing Bettys 01-10-2019 03:10 PM

^It's a bit of a tangent to discuss speed limits in terms of regular driving habits, but this video does a good job of explaining how speed limits end up being set.

Jmac 01-10-2019 03:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by white rocket (Post 8935259)
18 year old kid gets busted doing 100kph over the limit and the parents solution is to put a speed governor in and give the car back? Parenting 101 right there FailFish

Quote:

The Tesla was apparently supposed to have a 135-km/h limiter activated;

...

The crash happened on Seabreeze Boulevard, which has a 50-km/h speed limit and a 40-km/h curve. According to the crash report, the Model S was travelling at 186 km/h three seconds before the collision.
136 km/h over the speed limit ... into a corner with a 40 km/h recommended speed ... after the kid was busted doing 112 MPH in a 50 MPH zone ...

Even if the speed limiter was active at 135 km/h, this still would've been a major accident.

denham 01-10-2019 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AzNightmare (Post 8935263)
I guess in the ideal world, people would just figure out when too fast is too fast for their own good.

I quoted you earlier regarding this saying people aren't smart or don't care, but one example that goes against this (maybe other than the autobahn) is speed limits on rural roads in the UK. I grew up there and was just back there for vacation last year, and basically once you get out of a town or village, quite often the speed limit goes to 60mph (just under 100km/h). This is regardless of the type of road you're on. You can be on a road the width of one car with blind corners, and the limit will still be 60mph. When everyone is actually doing 10 to 30mph for most of this section of road. Not once in my vacation last year did I see someone blindly doing 60mph in a place where it wasn't safe. So yes maybe you're right that it is the case in an ideal world. But the problem here I think is you're basically always able to do the speed limit here, so we don't think that way.

For example, this road has a 60mph limit:
https://farm1.staticflickr.com/968/4...8265b5d8_c.jpgDSC00328 by Michael Denham, on Flickr

Jmac 01-10-2019 04:26 PM

People here can’t even understand the concept of not driving into oncoming traffic

donjalapeno 01-10-2019 05:30 PM

My parents wouldn't let me drive their Merc until I got my full license. So I saved up $500 from flipping burgers and they matched it and bought me a rebuilt high mileage Ford Focus station wagon. I got a speeding ticket once and they took it away for 2 months. My neighbor complained that I was speeding so they took it away again for a few weeks. I took the bus and rode my bike in the cold and rain so i learned my lesson.

Long story short. I thought they were dicks for doing that but hey i'm alive today and so are my friends.

The parents mentioned in the article knew the capabilities of the vehicle before they bought it and they were well aware that the kid would occasionally drive it.

Very heart breaking that lives were lost but the first time the kid was caught speeding should have been a huge red flag.

I hope they drown in court fees for blaming Tesla.

Jmac 01-10-2019 08:54 PM

I can’t even imagine what my parents would have done if I got caught doing 180+ in one of their cars. I can absolutely guarantee they wouldn’t have ever let me use their car again and that probably would’ve been the least of my problems.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.
Revscene.net cannot be held accountable for the actions of its members nor does the opinions of the members represent that of Revscene.net