Gotham. Best 50 dollar steak i've had.

the worst place i've had steak is at White Spot

Go check out my post in the "chop Review" thread.

It's total crap.

cant go wrong with the keg haha

Been 3 years since this was discussed. How's Hy's and Gotham's for steaks now? Any others?

Love the tenderloin? or was it filet mignon at Salade de fruits on 7th, good value too (24.99) Soooo good rare

black and blue... glowbal group. beside coast

Still Hy's is my fav.

The Keg is great. I've been hearing a lot about Gotham lately though. so might wanna check that out.

Onyx in white rock, had a better filet there than I've ever had at Morton's when it was open or hy's/gotham

went to hy's about 6 months ago and didnt find it that great.. got the porterhouse and a few sides.


going gothams in june!:) hope its good

^
None of my business but any reason why in June? :lol

work dinner lol so i dont have to pay

Wow, planned so far in advance, and it's not even the holiday season! :)

Black and Blue
Sunday Surf and Turf at $35 for a 16oz(i think) tenderloin

From my experience, Hy's, Keg's, and oddly enough, Cactus Club's steaks seem to be the most consistent. Like someone said earlier, Earls can be pretty hit or miss, depending on the Forno cook.

Personally, I was let down by Gothams. I kept hearing about it, and when I finally went, it was just average to me. Maybe I was just unlucky and had a bad chef? But I don't think I'll be going back. If you're going to run a $50 steak joint, you have to be consistent with every dish.

Damn! $35 surf and turf, not bad! compared to $50/steak @ Gotham's :fullofwin:

Is Gotham's worth it guys? Don't wanna drop $200+ if it's not lol

Any of the "best" steakhouses you can go and have a great meal at a reasonable price

To spend $200 you would almost have to TRY to spend that if your going with a group of 3-5 people

Drinks are all the costs really

Hy's is owned by the Keg.

All the chain restaurants get their steaks from the same big meat purveyor. Cactus, Earls, Milestones, Keg etc have their steaks cut/purchased from Intercity Packers

Will keep that in mind! :fullofwin:

enjoy

http://a5.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphot...23513438_n.jpg

^Wheres the surf on that? lol

on top of steak
it was scallop that night..i think..

Oh I see! The picture on the website shows a Lobster tail

I don't know about you guys but it seems like a sin to me to go to a good steakhouse and order the tenderloin. BORING!

That's like going to Hy's and ordering a porterhouse well done with chicken on the side.

I like the Gotham porterhouse and the bone-in rib steak. So flavourful!