God damn, Carly's retardedly good.
Her vocal runs are on par with the best singers are out there

The little one that wears a bow from Fifth Harmony is actually really good. I'm surprised she didn't make it as a solo Artist. She's better than Diamond and Beatrice. That would've been interesting if Britney had both her and Carly on her team.

Diamond wasn't bad tonight. But Carly...she sang the shit out of that Bieber song.

The unplugged band is Boyce Avenue, big YouTube band. Check 'em out...those guys killed it on Tate Stevens' songs.

Diamond is gone. Fifth Harmony survives elimination.

^ and Cece is finally gone.

Honestly, this is exactly how it should've been.

Funny seeing Tate up there with a bunch of kids :lawl:

I can't believe Tate still got #1.
He did horrible in his first song.

Yep, but like PJ said, he's the only one up there doing country *at all* (and pretty much has been the entire top 12), so he's getting all of the country-fan vote (even though what most of those people consider "country" is really just pop with a twang - I'd love to see Tate pull out some REAL country, some classic George Jones or something just to really fuck with their heads).

I swear this season was to showcase the WORST talent of today EXCEPT Carly Rose. She is basically competing against herself and I will consider music is officially dead if she doesn't win. Cece should have been kicked off a long time ago instead of taking up a spot for someone more deserving. I still can't believe Jennel/David Correy left before majority of the people left (or just got voted off recently)

I lol'd when Cece was like, "Oh, shit, no backup singers? I'm fucked!!!!"

If Tate wins..

:facepalm:

Tate can get shoved straight into the country scene seamlessly. He's good, but not $5 million good. Just a regular record deal should be good enough for him.

Based on talent, Carly should win, no question.

Based on marketability, maybe one of the groups.

Monster Kardashian seems to be shedding a lot of weight except in her face :suspicious:



and Simon Cowells swelling from his plastic surgery seems to have gone down quite a bit as well




mmmm britney

This show should be X-rated, because Britney just raped Carly on live TV with that howling version of "Imagine". GAH. Sorry Carly, but that was WAY over the top.

Simon is bang on, "it made a beautiful song fussy"

Simon is always right. Britney and Demi are airheads.

Carly's take on Imagine was just... no. You just don't do that to a Lennon song.

Strangely enough, I actually think Fifth Harmony did the best tonight. Though the Spanish shoved into Impossible didn't really do much for me.

Carly and Emblem 3 regressed, IMO.

Yep, all the talent in the world but no restraint. You don't always have to go for that note.

Carly doesn't have a sound of her own yet. She's not there as an artist. In all other aspects, she's amazing but I can't imagine what an original Carly Rose Sonenclar song would sound like...like I have no idea what her sound would be. That's just because she's 13 but still...it's stuff like this, taking Imagine and trying to spin it in her way but it just sounds like she's doing it just because she wants to go for the note, not because her singing is actually expressing any feelings of her own.

Her other song was pretty good though.

Yeah, thing is, Carly generally HAS shown restraint and taste in her performances... I get the feeling "that note" and the mish-mash of styles that the song wanders through, was Britney's idea.

Well, that was a bit of a rollercoaster ride............

I had a feeling 5th Harmony was going to make it it through.

Smug comment: I called it in my post above that they did the best last night :concentrate::ilied::fuckthatshit:

When it came down to E3 and Carly, I actually thought that Carly might've been going home. Carly/Britney really messed up bad on Imagine. I bet it pissed off a lot of Beatles fans. Too bad they didn't show the rankings. I was interested in whether or not that performance really did hurt her or not.

See Britney's face when Tate got through?

She knew she fucked Carly over.

Wasn't that bad. You didn't see Britney's face when 5th harmony went through?
Posted via RS Mobile

Wow, little surprised... I, too, thought Carly was gone mainly because of "Imagine". Bet the vote was *that* close too.

Ah well, I don't think Simon is too upset - you know he booked the studio for E3 months ago. I can see them having the biggest career out of all the finalists.

A few weeks ago, LA said himself, he wanted to sign E3 right then and there.

Tate is not worth 5 mill but at least deserves a record deal! E3 is the most marketable out of the bands too bad they got the boot and fifth harmony aren't that great thought they would be gong home today
Posted via RS Mobile

You mean LA?

Carly was most likely 1-2 like it has always been since week 1 of the live shows. Her first performance wasn't the greatest either but still got 2nd. I don't see people voting for 5th harmony over Carly but I guess we'll never know.