dangonay | 12-07-2013 09:50 PM | ^ Read that thread. Seems my guess was right - the person selling probably isn't the "owner". I imagine if you gave the police a description of the person you bought it from and it matched the "owner" they were returning the phone to, then they'd have some tough questions for them.
Find My iPhone/Activation Lock is still very useful to protect against this. The main thing is to never buy an iPhone with Find My iPhone already turned off. Ask the seller to turn it on and then back off, which proves they know the password for the Apple ID attached to the phone. The only way you could get burned by this is if the seller stole a phone and was lucky enough to get one where Find My iPhone was turned off. Or the "owner" who gave them the phone intentionally turned it off for the purpose of scamming someone. This would allow the "seller" to use their own Apple ID.
Let's say the latter was true. So the "seller" turns Find My iPhone off using whatever Apple ID they had with the phone to prove to you it's legit. You get the phone, attach it to your Apple ID and start using it. Then the police show up saying the phone was reported stolen.
Just how are the police going to give the "owner" back an iPhone that's attached to your Apple ID? How are they going to force you to provide your Apple ID password to erase the iPhone so it can be returned to the "owner"? Unless you cooperate the iPhone is essentially a brick. The police would need a court order to get you to provide the password.
Now the police are going to have to decide how much time to waste over a phone. The most likely scenario is for them to visit an Apple Store to see if they can "remove" the iPhone from your Apple ID and set it up for the "owner". I'm not even sure if that's possible or if they have that ability. But if they do, then I'm betting they know a few other things about the device. Like how many Apple ID's have been attached to it or when Find My iPhone was turned off (Apple sends an e-mail when you turn it off). This is the most interesting part - whether or not the "owner" turned it off, and what day they did (was it just before you bought it?).
I think the scenario described in that thread is far less likely with Find My iPhone. When the police realize that someone had to use a password to turn it off before selling it to you it puts a whole new spin on things. It's kinda like having your car stolen but there's no physical damage to the door lock or ignition (like when you have a key "given" to you so you can "steal" the car). I think the police are going to want to know how the person who supposedly stole the phone was able to turn Find My iPhone off without having some connection to the "owner".
Personally, I have no worries about buying a used iPhone/iPad if the seller is able to turn Find My iPhone off for me in person. |