REVscene Automotive Forum

REVscene Automotive Forum (https://www.revscene.net/forums/)
-   Vancouver Auto Chat (https://www.revscene.net/forums/vancouver-auto-chat_173/)
-   -   Electric and Hybrid Car Thread (https://www.revscene.net/forums/706431-electric-hybrid-car-thread.html)

AstulzerRZD 05-29-2024 11:20 AM

Gotcha, so...

Tesla: 20-40c/kwh
City of Vancouver wants 26c/minute at 62kW, about 26c/kw
BC Hydro: 35c/kwh
Petro Canada wants 50c/minute at 50kW, about 50c/kw
Journie station: 65c/kwh

So for local public stations, 30c/kw at 5.6km/kw puts you at $5/100km, or like 2.7L/100km... amazing.
Even for highway trips 4.6km/kw at a more expensive charger it's still like 6L/100km

noclue 05-29-2024 12:12 PM

Yeah I have a model Y and I’ll never use it for road trips. Dont care about superchargers when you have to proactively plan your charges or cant go to rural areas. I rented a diesel suburban and on the highway I got 7L/100km at 100km/h.

EvoFire 05-29-2024 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AstulzerRZD (Post 9137768)
Good news: EV road trip was fine, Electrify America seems to be working really reliably

Bad news: WTF on a EV6 at 75-85mph, this is more expensive to run than a 330i and almost M340i expensive

Really bad news: girlfriend was mad that chargers weren't near any nice restaurants or cute places. Finding a reasonable charger is really hard.

Trip: Cape Cod to NYC

For sake of comparison, 89/91 is $4.2ish per gallon.
IMO reasonable comparison for the power and comfort.

Charge 0: 100%, 305 miles stated range

Charge 1: 62.5kW via ChargePoint, $6.32 for 23kWh over 24 minutes at .28/kwh
124.5 miles, 3.5mi/kw, equivalent 82mpg or 2.9l/100km
City driving and cheap charging is where EVs really shine

Charge 2: 30kWh on 125kWh shared charger, Free for 2.5kWh
A 125kWh charger gives 80kWh to the first car to arrive and 30kWH to me?
Abandoned charge.

Charge 3: up to 235kW via Electrify America, $11.32 for 20kWh over 13 minutes at .56/kWh
125.1 mi, 3mi/kWh

Charge 4: 80-110kW via Revel, $26 for 46kWh over 30 minutes at .49/kWh
101mi, 2.9mi/kWh, equivalent 26mpg

330i RWD got 42mpg highway on Car and Driver 200mile 75mph test
330i xDrive got 36mpg
M340i AWD is rated for 33mpg
Overall cost: 35mpg or 6.7l/100km.
It's great that EVs are road trippable but they're defs more citi/suburb cars than road trippers


Avis should've just given me the Toyota Crown (42 mpg rated)/Prius (56 mpg rated) I asked for.

I tell ppl that some of those chargers, what you see is not what you get. That charge 2 exemplifies that. Various YT reviewers have also said chargers are always broken. And then the Richmond Center and Hope charger lineups... Yeah no thanks not with kids in the car.

AstulzerRZD 05-29-2024 12:58 PM

I think the days of "broken chargers" are a lot less common now.

EvGo and Electrify America have 4+ chargers at most malls and highway rest stops.
You do pay dearly for them at 56c USD per kWh.

Access to parking lots where the cheaper ChargePoint DC fast chargers are is a lot more vafriable tho.

68style 05-29-2024 01:22 PM

Now they need to start solving the emerging problem of crackheads cutting all the charging station cables for copper.... can't leave anything even remotely nice just sitting around anymore without someone wanting to wreck it.

AstulzerRZD 05-29-2024 01:23 PM

Shell's "sky-EV" tech in Seattle's pretty cool

They have "curbside" chargers where the cables come down from the power lines in the sky when you activate a charging session

Pretty fast L2 chargers (9.6kw instead of the usual 6.3 with chargepoint) and .21/kWh is hella cheap

AstulzerRZD 05-29-2024 01:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by noclue (Post 9137807)
Yeah I have a model Y and I’ll never use it for road trips. Dont care about superchargers when you have to proactively plan your charges or cant go to rural areas. I rented a diesel suburban and on the highway I got 7L/100km at 100km/h.

Who's renting diesel Suburbans?

68style 05-29-2024 01:29 PM

LOL I didn't even know a diesel Suburban existed!!

AstulzerRZD 05-29-2024 01:40 PM

Diesel Wrangler and F150 were discontinued because of how problematic they were.

GM's V8s keep blowing their valvetrains so the diesel might be the choice.
Occasional regen / cooling system glitches seem pretty mild compared to 5.3/6.2 problems.

RabidRat 05-29-2024 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AstulzerRZD (Post 9137791)
I think is more the cost of fast charging that blew my mind.
60 cents per kw is a lot

60c/kWh seems really high, almost double what i had paid on my last road trip. is this because you didn't get an Electrify America Pass+? or because you converted to CAD? or both?

G 05-29-2024 04:27 PM

My friend's townhouse has a SWTCH charging station installed on his underground parking stall - is it essentially just a company that sets up the charging infrastructure for the strata and charges the user for using it?

AstulzerRZD 05-29-2024 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RabidRat (Post 9137846)
60c/kWh seems really high, almost double what i had paid on my last road trip. is this because you didn't get an Electrify America Pass+? or because you converted to CAD? or both?

Yeah, stated charging rate is .59-.63 USD in NY/MA/RI.
Pass+ would've been $7 to reduce charging cost to .44-.47/kWh

Ulic Qel-Droma 05-29-2024 05:53 PM

https://www.drivencarguide.co.nz/new...-2100km-range/

2100km Corolla priced

What’s the catch???

AstulzerRZD 05-29-2024 06:33 PM

2 things:

1) this has a 16.5 gallon gas tank, most Toyota hybrids have a smaller one (10-11 gallons)

2) China uses the domestic CLTC range estimate, which prioritizes slow speed, start-stop city traffic, which is more prevalent in China. It leads to inflated numbers for EVs and hybrid vehicles vs. ICE because those cars are very efficient in that kind of use thanks to brake regen, while being much less so on the highway like the EPA tests at.

2100km CLTC on a PHEV/BEV is more like 1400KM or so on EPA combined.

3) If you take the Corolla Hybrid's combined fuel economy and multiply by 16.5 gallons, it already does 1400KM. Passat diesel did like 1300km back in 2015.

tldr big gas tank

is350 05-29-2024 10:57 PM

^not really... there's a couple chinese tests involving mixed hwy speed (averaging 90km/h) and stop and go traffic, also driving from low elevation to higher elevation location, car even did 2409km in one test...you can say BYD paid them, but once the cars hit the street, we shall see their real range is, I doubt it will be far from what they claim, BYD is the biggest EV automaker in the world for a reason.
Even if you give corolla hybrid or the passat diesel the same size gas tank, their ranges will still be lower than this BYD at least from what they claim. hopefully real world test proves it.


And all of that for under $15k USD, that is a no brainer price in China or in NA, but we know they won't be allowed here

AstulzerRZD 05-30-2024 05:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by is350 (Post 9137898)
^not really... there's a couple chinese tests involving mixed hwy speed (averaging 90km/h) and stop and go traffic, also driving from low elevation to higher elevation location, car even did 2409km in one test...you can say BYD paid them, but once the cars hit the street, we shall see their real range is, I doubt it will be far from what they claim, BYD is the biggest EV automaker in the world for a reason.
Even if you give corolla hybrid or the passat diesel the same size gas tank, their ranges will still be lower than this BYD at least from what they claim. hopefully real world test proves it.


And all of that for under $15k USD, that is a no brainer price in China or in NA, but we know they won't be allowed here

To be fair, the 46% thermal efficiency is a hell of an achievement and BYD makes some of the best batteries.

I wonder how much effort they’ve put into other parts of the car like crash structures. My TAs at school worked on the Cadillac CT6 and saved a 100+ lbs out of the rear crash structure

AstulzerRZD 05-30-2024 01:20 PM

I'm a glutton for punishment, so I booked a Model 3 from Avis for a YVR > SEA > YVR day trip.

$84 CAD for the rental is maybe $20 more than what I'd pay for gas to drive 450km.

I'm expecting a J1772 adapter but don't expect to have a CCS adapter provided.

Supercharger rates are ~.3-.48/kWh in Seattle.

is350 05-30-2024 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AstulzerRZD (Post 9137902)
To be fair, the 46% thermal efficiency is a hell of an achievement and BYD makes some of the best batteries.

I wonder how much effort they’ve put into other parts of the car like crash structures. My TAs at school worked on the Cadillac CT6 and saved a 100+ lbs out of the rear crash structure

Typically Chinese cars have not performed well in Euro or NA crash tests, I wonder too about the new BYD model, no results yet online as far as I can tell. I don't have high hopes

AstulzerRZD 05-30-2024 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by is350 (Post 9137997)
Typically Chinese cars have not performed well in Euro or NA crash tests, I wonder too about the new BYD model, no results yet online as far as I can tell. I don't have high hopes

The Toyota Nimh batteries are ancient but full rebuilds are only 3k .. wonder what the BYD rebuild cost is.

Looking at BYD blade battery, individual cells are replaceable which is really good.

Toyota made a really big deal about hitting 40/41% thermal efficiency on their Dynamic Force motors. If BYD really did hit 46%, that's insane.

Crash structure wise ... that stuff all adds weight

radeonboy 05-30-2024 01:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by is350 (Post 9137997)
Typically Chinese cars have not performed well in Euro or NA crash tests, I wonder too about the new BYD model, no results yet online as far as I can tell. I don't have high hopes

You can watch the Euro NCAP ratings here for a number of Chinese cars. I haven't watched them all but they don't perform notably worse than their same-class competitors?

https://www.youtube.com/@EuroNCAP_forsafercars/videos

Linking the first 3 Chinese vehicles on their channel here:

and some BYDs:

AstulzerRZD 05-30-2024 01:53 PM

Looking at the crash test, Euro NCAP is a LOT easier.

Euro NCAP Frontal crash is 50% overlap at 50kmh
This is like the old 40% overlap at 50kmh that cars did well at since like the late 2000s.

IIHS small overlap is 25% overlap at 64kmh.
That's 60% more kinetic energy concentrated on half the area.

Same with the side crash,
EuroNCAP are doing 50kmh, 3100 lb barrier
IIHS are doing 59kmh, 4200lb barrier.
That's 80%+ more kinetic energy

All that said, EVs should be far easier to design crash structures for since they've got more 'room' to crumple and absorb force

TypeRNammer 05-30-2024 04:38 PM

Spotted a VW ID Buzz on the road with BC plates.

It's pretty wild looking in person, big electric toaster box on wheels.

https://i.imgur.com/pnRXLs9.jpeg

https://i.imgur.com/uYPLi5M.jpeg

Badhobz 05-30-2024 05:22 PM

Omg me wanty !!!!!

AstulzerRZD 05-30-2024 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TypeRNammer (Post 9138020)
Spotted a VW ID Buzz on the road with BC plates.

It's pretty wild looking in person, big electric toaster box on wheels.

https://i.imgur.com/pnRXLs9.jpeg

https://i.imgur.com/uYPLi5M.jpeg

3 car garage - ID Buzz, Wrangler 4XE, and 981??

BIC_BAWS 05-30-2024 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TypeRNammer (Post 9138020)
Spotted a VW ID Buzz on the road with BC plates.

It's pretty wild looking in person, big electric toaster box on wheels.

https://i.imgur.com/pnRXLs9.jpeg

https://i.imgur.com/uYPLi5M.jpeg

I believe this is one of the VW dealership owner's personal car. From what I know, the car is supposedly imported from Italy and it's the only one in NA. I'm not sure of the lengths he had to go through to get it passed for BC roads, considering its a new car not available in NA.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:27 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
SEO by vBSEO ©2011, Crawlability, Inc.
Revscene.net cannot be held accountable for the actions of its members nor does the opinions of the members represent that of Revscene.net