if there's an outbreak in the US would Canada close its border?

doubt it, same deal

If this hypothetical outbreak in the US is as big as the coronavirus outbreak is in China, you'd be out of your mind to think that Canadians wouldn't be screaming to have our borders closed. The federal government would probably be reluctant at first to close the borders, but as the epidemic escalates and public cry for border closure escalates, it'd be silly to think the Canadian gov wouldn't cave into the demands of Canadians. If they didn't, the governing party would be punished for years to come at the polls.

lmao like how Liberals got punished for SNC scandal?

they might restrict, doubt any govt in Ottawa would have the balls to completely close off crossings (esp. Windsor/Detroit) and cancel all US-bound flights (just think of how many connections are made in the US) for a month or three

our economy would go in a freefall if we cut own our jugular and cease all trade with the US even for weeks

The thing that the "100% closed borders" people aren't taking into account is that HK kind of needs a somewhat open border in order to keep logistics flowing. We rely on China for food and quite a few essential goods. Shutting down the border completely means none of this will be able to make it through anymore.

Sure middle class people and above can go to the supermarket and buy food from other countries, but poorer people rely on low cost meat from China, and especially vegetables.

I guess we could look to other countries for produce, like Thailand, but will the cost be as low? Do countries like Vietnam even export many goods?

I am 100% in favour of strict border controls, but I'm against the idea of a 100% closure to China. I think leaving SZ Bay bridge and Macau bridge can allow things to flow through, while at the same time severely limit the amount of potentially infected people from coming in. Be extra strict with temperature checks and scrutinize their travel. There are plenty of people who NEED to come in, to Hong Kong's benefit, and are at relatively low risk of having the virus.

This current closure should bring daily mainlanders crossing via land down to 2000, from like 20-30K before. That's not zero, but it's pretty damn significant and maybe manageable.

If the government wasn't literally evil, then maybe people would be willing to work with them. But it seems to be that only the most extreme solution will do because of their history.

If they would have done THIS closure on DAY ONE, HK may be at like 5 or 10 infections instead of 20, and people wouldn't be as freaked out.

But nope. Carrie Lam just kept admonishing people, calling them "radicals" while stubbornly closing the borders more and more each day FailFish

Hong Kongers are not demanding a 100% closed border from Carrie right now. As I understand it, they just want the border closed to Mainland Chinese people. Goods and stuff are still expected to come in?

At least that's the gist I have always been getting.

I always got the gist that they want to fully close the border. If you want the border closure to be effective, than you limit hongers leaving to the mainland too.

Mainlanders can't just freely enter unless they have shenzhen hukou (even thats once a week, max 7 day stay) or an entry permit that was issued before the outbreak( new entry permits have been suspended after the outbreak)

They can try for transit through HK for a flight to an international destination, but HK immigration can refuse if they feel such transit is not valid.

I'd be more worried about hongers going to the mainland and coming back with the virus. For example the cruise passenger that got tested positive when the ship was docking at Yokahoma.

Who's to bring in these goods? They just drop it off at the border and someone picks it up?

First death in Hong Kong, 39 year old male from Wuhan

First death in Philippines was a 44 year old male from Wuhan

These are the first 2 deaths outside China. No idea if they had underlying conditions, but the age is pretty scary.

chances of YVR rejecting all Taipei flights in March? (Italy did it because of WHO's designation of 'Taipei, China')

Only retard countries will be blocking Taiwan

via rail, Just have a few guys with right hazmat clothing to drive it over and let it isolate for a few days.

the physician who tried to warn about the outbreak then got detained contracted the disease :(

https://www.cnn.com/2020/02/03/asia/...hnk/index.html

Whats worse is the dad who was quarantined, but his disabled kid was left home alone, and died. The father had plead online for help too, but after a week his son was found dead at home

That's fucked

I dunno, but I'm sure that can be arranged.

Also, rarely mentioned in the "border-closing" request is a condition where Hong Kongers returning to Hong Kong (from Mainland China) will be placed under a 14 day quarantine.

My cousins fiancé is from the mainland, and her pass into hk is up, they won't give her an extension, so he's bringing her into sz today, guess he'll get quarantined when he comes back

In taiwan rn masks are hard to find, but if you go into miniso it's filled with the novelty marvel fabric ones, almost couldn't resist :lol

The number is really growing... 427 death in china.
Do we really have 4 confirmed cases in Canada? I thought it was 3.
https://gisanddata.maps.arcgis.com/a...23467b48e9ecf6

Borders might be 100% locked down when he tries to come back, possibly no flights allowed either :heckno:

We've been trying to get my wife's dad to come down here, but nope he refuses.

^ My aunt went back to China in November and after I discovered about coronavirus in early January. We told her to come back but refused...

Have you talked to her about it since? Some places are more at risk than others, even when not locked down. I wouldn't want to be in Guangzhou for instance

Wow things are moving fast now eh, hopefully thing s don't get worse, in terms of ppl contracting the virus

Have some relatives in China, they've got Canadian visas, and foreign passports etc, but they're /shrug about leaving, yet are afraid to leave home too, makes no sense

I have relatives all over the world looking for mask; and here are some complaints.

1) Most shipments of masks from China are locked down; unable to ship out from China to outside. Customs will just take them. There were 10 boxes declared lost.
2) With masks being shipped out, there has been thefts also. When you call the courier company; they will pay you insurance + 15% of declared value. Tons of anger but you can't not declare them as mask and you can't over declare the content's value.
3) My uncle is going to fly to Indonesia to personally pick up mask to bring back to HK.
which I think is f-ed up.... to go thru all this for a mask. Desperate times I guess.

Dude things are going to get much, much worse before they get better. It's barely even started yet. Incubation alone can be up to two weeks and we're not even at that point since this thread started. Barring a miracle cure, if it really is R0 3.8, the numbers are going to be staggering before they level out and start to go down. Not to freak anyone out, but this could very possibly be a pandemic the likes of which we haven't even considered possible in the last 100 years. Thankfully we also have technology to fight it, such as the spread of information and the ability to react with quarantines, monitoring, and border closures (lul).

The locked down cities in China are going to be so, so fucked when this is over. The "best case scenario" is that only a few million people get infected, and a few thousand die (remember SARS killed around 300 people) and that only wonderful scenario only happens if this is mostly contained within these cities. It's too late to save them. Why do you think countries are bailing people out of there? Anyone left in these cities are pretty much left to get sick and hopefully not die.

I totally understand the notion of not wanting to ditch your home, and just worry about getting by, but at the same time you can't just live your life like nothing is going on if you're in China or even Hong Kong (and possibly elsewhere eventually)

Why are Canadian-Chinese people not wanting to leave China to come back to Canada? Is it the risk of expose on route?

The same reason as why HK'ers with international passports didn't want to leave when riots were at it's height. Same reason why some don't want to leave when there are forest fires. Home is home. I bet most of us wouldn't leave here if it happened in Vancouver.